This is what our simulator gets for the Paladin Protection at level 60: the gear the optimizer finds among the items known so far (dungeons, raid and crafted gear), the preset talents, the rotation followed and the damage of every ability over a 180-second fight against a stationary boss.
A build has 51 points. A tier-n talent only unlocks after 5 × (n − 1) points spent higher in the same tree (the numbers on the left of each tree give the tier and the points required): some points are therefore gate points, taken to reach a talent further down.
46 in Protection and 5 in Retribution. The talents that weigh the most (DPS lost without them, measured in the simulator): Holy Shield (−147), Reckoning (−92), Improved Righteous Fury (−30), Iron Creed (−29), Precision (−22), Redoubt (−20), Deflection (−20), Anticipation (−19).
Measured at about zero or not simulated (gate points, filler or non-damage effects): Divine Intellect, Sacred Duty, Templar's Bulwark, Shield Specialization, Swift Judgement, Shieldsworn, Stoicism, Guardian's Favor.
Notes of November 3: Righteous Fury gives +33% threat on everything and +90% more on Holy damage (the simulator adds them), Improved Righteous Fury cuts damage taken by 3 / 6 / 9%, Iron Creed has only 3 ranks (+10% Holy Strike threat per rank), One-Handed Weapon Specialization is gone and Holy Shield deals less damage.
The talents that pay the most: Holy Shield (−147.2 score), Reckoning (−91.9 score), Improved Righteous Fury (−30.3 score).
Points with no measured effect in the simulator (gate, utility or an effect that is not simulated): Guardian's Favor, Templar's Bulwark, Shield Specialization, Stoicism, Shieldsworn.
A talent's value is what the specialization loses when it is taken out of the build, on the same character and the same 180-second simulation.
| Talent | Tier | Measured value |
|---|---|---|
| Holy Shield 1/1 ProtectionIncreases chance to block by 30% for 10 sec, and deals 75 Holy damage for each attack blocked while active. Damage caused by Holy Shield causes 20% additional threat. Each block expends a charge. 4 charges. | 5 | −147.2 score without it (8.5%) |
| Reckoning 5/5 ProtectionGives you a 40% chance after Blocking and a 100% chance after receiving a non-periodic critical strike to gain an extra attack. Stores up to 4 extra attacks. Cannot occur from Blocks more than once every … sec. | 5 | −91.9 score without it (5.3%) |
| Improved Righteous Fury 3/3 ProtectionWhile Righteous Fury is active, all damage taken is reduced by 9%. | 4 | −30.3 score without it (1.8%) |
| Iron Creed 3/3 ProtectionIncreases the threat generated by your Holy Strike ability by 30%. While Righteous Fury is active, Holy Strike also reduces your damage taken by 6% for 6 sec. | 6 | −29.0 score without it (1.7%) |
| Precision 3/3 ProtectionImproves your chance to hit by 3%. | 2 | −22.1 score without it (1.3%) |
| Redoubt 5/5 ProtectionDamaging melee attacks against you have a 10% chance to increase your chance to block by 30%. Lasts 10 sec or 5 blocks. | 1 | −20.3 score without it (1.2%) |
| Deflection 5/5 RetributionIncreases your Parry chance by 5%. | 1 | −19.9 score without it (1.1%) |
| Anticipation 5/5 ProtectionIncreases your Defense Skill by 20. | 4 | −18.7 score without it (1.1%) |
| Toughness 5/5 ProtectionIncreases your armor value from items by 10%. | 3 | −18.6 score without it (1.1%) |
| Divine Intellect 5/5 ProtectionIncreases your total Intellect by 10%. | 1 | negligible measured effect |
| Sacred Duty 2/2 ProtectionReduces the cooldown of your Divine Shield, Divine Protection, and Templar's Bulwark spells by -60 sec, and reduces the duration of Forbearance by -10 sec. | 2 | negligible measured effect |
| Swift Judgement 1/1 ProtectionUnleash the energy of a Seal spell upon an enemy. Does not consume the Seal. Refer to individual Seals for Judgement effect. Does not share a cooldown with your Judgement ability. | 4 | negligible measured effect |
| Guardian's Favor 2/2 ProtectionReduces the cooldown of your Blessing of Protection by 2 min and increases the duration of your Blessing of Freedom by 6 sec. | 2 | no simulated effect |
| Templar's Bulwark 1/1 ProtectionWhen activated, this ability grants you an absorb shield equal to 100% of your maximum health for 8 sec. Applies Forbearance for 1 min. Cannot be cast while Forbearance is active. | 3 | no simulated effect |
| Shield Specialization 2/2 ProtectionIncreases the amount of damage absorbed by your shield by 30%, and gives your blocks a 100% chance to restore 4% of your maximum Mana. May only occur once every 3 sec. | 3 | no simulated effect |
| Stoicism 2/2 ProtectionReduces the duration of Stun and Charm effects on you by 20%. | 5 | no simulated effect |
| Shieldsworn 1/1 ProtectionReduces the cooldown of your Holy Strike ability by -4 sec. Additionally, Holy Strike now strikes with your shield, triggering your active Holy Shield and Shield Specialization talents without consuming their charges or triggering their cooldowns, and allowing you to Block spells for 6 sec. | 7 | no simulated effect |
The first 14 seconds of the simulated fight: the hits that deal direct damage, in order.
| Ability | Share | DPS | Casts / min | Crits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| White (main hand) | 53.1% | 227.4 | — | 30% |
| Windfury Totem | 11.6% | 49.5 | 6.1 | 30% |
| Holy Strike | 10.4% | 44.4 | 6.0 | 34% |
| Seal of Righteousness | 9.9% | 42.4 | 36.9 | 34% |
| Holy Shield | 7.6% | 32.5 | 6.0 | 17% |
| Judgement of Righteousness | 7.0% | 30 | 6.0 | 34% |
| Smokey's Lighter | 0.4% | 1.9 | 0.7 | — |
Rule applied: at most one scroll, one elixir or flask, one food and one weapon oil at a time (the rule given for Forever, which the client tables cannot confirm). The simulator picks the best of each slot for this specialization; the best consumables and their gain are in its guide.
A 180-second fight against a stationary level-63 boss, the raid buffs and consumables of the class's family, a standard race (Human, Orc for Shaman) with the racials read from the game client (WoW Classic's weapon skill no longer exists in Forever: weapon specializations give critical strike chance), item effects on. Level-60 base stats and several Classic values are estimates, flagged in the simulator. Results will move with the game.
The core mechanics (attack table, rage, mana regeneration, resistances, Classic base stats and race bonuses) come from the open-source simulator WoWSims (MIT licence): github.com/wowsims/classic
World of Warcraft, Warcraft and Blizzard Entertainment are trademarks of Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. BrokenMeta.gg is an independent site: it is not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by Blizzard.