This is what our simulator gets for the Warrior Protection at level 60: the gear the optimizer finds among the items known so far (dungeons, raid and crafted gear), the preset talents, the rotation followed and the damage of every ability over a 180-second fight against a stationary boss.
A build has 51 points. A tier-n talent only unlocks after 5 × (n − 1) points spent higher in the same tree (the numbers on the left of each tree give the tier and the points required): some points are therefore gate points, taken to reach a talent further down.
40 in Protection and 11 in Arms. The talents that weigh the most (DPS lost without them, measured in the simulator): Defiance (−251), Improved Revenge (−226), Bastion (−118), Shield Slam (−59), Deflection (−30), Focused Rage (−27), Shield Specialization (−16), Anticipation (−15).
Measured at about zero or not simulated (gate points, filler or non-damage effects): Iron Will, Improved Bloodrage, Master of Defense, Last Stand, Improved Sunder Armor, Vanguard, Improved Heroic Strike, Improved Charge, Improved Tactical Mastery, Concussion Blow.
Notes of November 3: Defensive Stance gives 80% extra threat (30% before) and Defiance 7 / 13 / 20% (5 / 10 / 15%).
The talents that pay the most: Defiance (−251.5 score), Improved Revenge (−225.6 score), Bastion (−117.7 score).
Points with no measured effect in the simulator (gate, utility or an effect that is not simulated): Iron Will, Improved Charge, Improved Tactical Mastery, Last Stand, Vanguard, Concussion Blow.
A talent's value is what the specialization loses when it is taken out of the build, on the same character and the same 180-second simulation.
| Talent | Tier | Measured value |
|---|---|---|
| Defiance 3/3 ProtectionIncreases all threat generated in Defensive stance by an additional 20% while a shield is equipped. | 3 | −251.5 score without it (8.7%) |
| Improved Revenge 3/3 ProtectionIncreases damage dealt by your Revenge ability by 60%. | 2 | −225.6 score without it (7.8%) |
| Bastion 5/5 ProtectionIncreases all damage you deal by 10% while a shield is equipped. | 6 | −117.7 score without it (4.1%) |
| Shield Slam 1/1 ProtectionSlam the target with your shield, causing 430 damage, increased by your Block Value, and has a 50% chance of dispelling 1 magic effect on the target. Causes a very high amount of threat. | 7 | −58.9 score without it (2.0%) |
| Deflection 5/5 ArmsIncreases your Parry chance by 5%. | 1 | −29.6 score without it (1.0%) |
| Focused Rage 3/3 ProtectionReduces the Rage cost of your offensive abilities by 3. | 5 | −27.4 score without it (0.9%) |
| Shield Specialization 5/5 ProtectionIncreases your chance to Block attacks with your shield by 5% and grants you a 100% chance to generate 5 Rage when you Block. | 1 | −16.4 score without it (0.6%) |
| Anticipation 5/5 ProtectionIncreases your Defense Skill by 20. | 2 | −15.2 score without it (0.5%) |
| Improved Heroic Strike 3/3 ArmsReduces the cost of your Heroic Strike ability by 3 Rage. | 1 | −13.6 score without it (0.5%) |
| Master of Defense 2/2 ProtectionGrants you a 100% chance to generate 5 Rage when you Dodge or Parry while a shield is equipped. | 3 | −11.3 score without it (0.4%) |
| Improved Bloodrage 2/2 ProtectionIncreases all the Rage generated by your Bloodrage ability by 50%. | 1 | negligible measured effect |
| Improved Sunder Armor 3/3 ProtectionReduces the Rage cost of your Sunder Armor ability by 3. | 4 | negligible measured effect |
| Iron Will 5/5 ProtectionReduces the duration of Stun and Fear effects inflicted on you by 15%. | 1 | no simulated effect |
| Improved Charge 2/2 ArmsIncreases the Rage generated by your Charge ability by 6. | 2 | no simulated effect |
| Improved Tactical Mastery 1/3 ArmsTactical Mastery lets you retain up to an additional 5 Rage when you change stances. | 2 | no simulated effect |
| Last Stand 1/1 ProtectionWhen activated, this ability temporarily grants you 30% of your maximum health for 20 sec. After the effect expires, the health is lost. | 3 | no simulated effect |
| Vanguard 1/1 ProtectionYour Charge ability is now usable while in Defensive Stance. | 4 | no simulated effect |
| Concussion Blow 1/1 ProtectionStuns the target for 5 sec. | 5 | no simulated effect |
The first 14 seconds of the simulated fight: the hits that deal direct damage, in order.
| Ability | Share | DPS | Casts / min | Crits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heroic Strike | 45.4% | 328.2 | 41.2 | 34% |
| Revenge | 27.1% | 195.7 | 10.1 | 34% |
| Shield Slam | 17.8% | 128.9 | 10.0 | 34% |
| Windfury Totem | 8.4% | 60.4 | 11.8 | 36% |
| White (main hand) | 1.1% | 8.3 | — | 36% |
| Smokey's Lighter | 0.2% | 1.8 | 0.7 | — |
Rule applied: at most one scroll, one elixir or flask, one food and one weapon oil at a time (the rule given for Forever, which the client tables cannot confirm). The simulator picks the best of each slot for this specialization; the best consumables and their gain are in its guide.
A 180-second fight against a stationary level-63 boss, the raid buffs and consumables of the class's family, a standard race (Human, Orc for Shaman) with the racials read from the game client (WoW Classic's weapon skill no longer exists in Forever: weapon specializations give critical strike chance), item effects on. Level-60 base stats and several Classic values are estimates, flagged in the simulator. Results will move with the game.
The core mechanics (attack table, rage, mana regeneration, resistances, Classic base stats and race bonuses) come from the open-source simulator WoWSims (MIT licence): github.com/wowsims/classic
World of Warcraft, Warcraft and Blizzard Entertainment are trademarks of Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. BrokenMeta.gg is an independent site: it is not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by Blizzard.