This is what our simulator gets for the Priest Shadow at level 60: the gear the optimizer finds among the items known so far (dungeons, raid and crafted gear), the preset talents, the rotation followed and the damage of every ability over a 180-second fight against a stationary boss.
A build has 51 points. A tier-n talent only unlocks after 5 × (n − 1) points spent higher in the same tree (the numbers on the left of each tree give the tier and the points required): some points are therefore gate points, taken to reach a talent further down.
32 in Shadow and 19 in Discipline. The talents that weigh the most (DPS lost without them, measured in the simulator): Mind Flay (−352, 39%), Shadowform (−252, 28%), Darkness (−81), Shadow Weaving (−75), Improved Mind Flay (−65), Shadow Focus (−46), Improved Shadow Word: Pain (−22), Improved Mind Blast (−20).
Measured at about zero or not simulated (gate points, filler or non-damage effects): Spirit Tap, Vampiric Embrace, Devouring Contagion, Power in Light, Mental Agility, Inner Focus, Meditation, Mental Strength.
Devouring Plague comes back every 24 s (60 s before the patch), Shadow Word: Death every 18 s and Improved Mind Flay raises each Mind Flay tick by 10 / 20% over the previous one. Mental Strength only gives 2% Intellect per rank now.
The talents that pay the most: Mind Flay (−351.8 DPS), Shadowform (−252.4 DPS), Darkness (−80.8 DPS).
Points with no measured effect in the simulator (gate, utility or an effect that is not simulated): Spirit Tap, Power in Light, Vampiric Embrace.
A talent's value is what the specialization loses when it is taken out of the build, on the same character and the same 180-second simulation.
| Talent | Tier | Measured value |
|---|---|---|
| Mind Flay 1/1 ShadowAssault the target's mind with Shadow energy, causing 63 Shadow damage over 3 sec and slowing their movement speed by 50%. | 3 | −351.8 DPS without it (39.5%) |
| Shadowform 1/1 ShadowAssume Shadowform, increasing your Shadow damage by 10%, reducing the Mana cost of all Shadow spells by 50%, increasing the critical strike damage bonus of your Shadow spells by 100%, and reducing Physical damage taken by you by 15%. However, you may not cast healing spells while in this form. | 7 | −252.4 DPS without it (28.3%) |
| Darkness 5/5 ShadowIncreases your Shadow damage done by 10%. | 6 | −80.8 DPS without it (9.1%) |
| Shadow Weaving 3/3 ShadowYour Shadow damage spells have a 100% chance to increase the Shadow damage the target takes from you by 2% for 15 sec, stacking up to 5 times. | 4 | −75.3 DPS without it (8.4%) |
| Improved Mind Flay 2/2 ShadowEach instance of damage of Mind Flay deals 20% more damage than its previous instance of damage. | 3 | −64.8 DPS without it (7.3%) |
| Shadow Focus 5/5 ShadowImproves your chance to hit with Shadow spells by 5%. | 1 | −46.0 DPS without it (5.2%) |
| Improved Shadow Word: Pain 2/2 ShadowIncreases the duration of your Shadow Word: Pain spell by 6 sec. | 2 | −21.9 DPS without it (2.5%) |
| Improved Mind Blast 5/5 ShadowReduces the cooldown of your Mind Blast spell by 2.5 sec. | 2 | −19.5 DPS without it (2.2%) |
| Twin Disciplines 5/5 DisciplineIncreases the damage and healing of your instant cast spells by 5%. | 1 | −16.8 DPS without it (1.9%) |
| Mental Strength 2/5 DisciplineIncreases your total Intellect by 4%. | 2 | negligible measured effect |
| Mental Agility 3/3 DisciplineReduces the mana cost of your Smite, Holy Fire, and instant cast spells by 10%. | 3 | negligible measured effect |
| Meditation 3/3 DisciplineAllows 50% of your Mana regeneration to continue while casting. | 3 | negligible measured effect |
| Inner Focus 1/1 DisciplineWhen activated, reduces the Mana cost of your next spell by 100% and increases its critical effect chance by 25% if it is a non-periodic spell and capable of a critical effect. | 3 | negligible measured effect |
| Devouring Contagion 2/2 ShadowReduces the mana cost of your Devouring Plague by 50%. Targets that die while Devouring Plague is active spreads it, jumping to 2 nearby enemies within 10 yds for the remaining duration. | 5 | negligible measured effect |
| Spirit Tap 5/5 ShadowGives you a 100% chance to increase your Spirit by 100% for 15 sec after killing a non-trivial target or when an enemy afflicted by your Vampiric Embrace dies. For the duration, 50% of your Mana regeneration will continue while casting. | 1 | no simulated effect |
| Power in Light 5/5 DisciplineYour Smite and Penance spells deal 10% increased damage to targets afflicted with your Holy Fire or Shadow Word: Pain. | 1 | no simulated effect |
| Vampiric Embrace 1/1 ShadowAfflicts your target with Shadow energy that causes all party members to be healed for 20% of any Shadow spell damage you deal for 30 sec. | 4 | no simulated effect |
The first 14 seconds of the simulated fight: the hits that deal direct damage, in order.
| Ability | Share | DPS | Casts / min | Crits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mind Flay | 41.6% | 370.8 | 12.5 | 26% |
| Shadow Word: Pain | 21.4% | 191 | 3.0 | 26% |
| Mind Blast | 18.5% | 164.8 | 7.6 | 26% |
| Devouring Plague | 11.5% | 102.5 | 2.3 | 26% |
| Shadow Word: Death | 6.7% | 59.8 | 2.7 | 26% |
| Ignition | 0.2% | 2 | 2.0 | — |
Each curve shows the simulated character's DPS as a stat is added on top of its gear: the left point is the current gear. A dashed line marks the estimated cap, the point where every extra point is worth less than 20% of what it gave at the start.
Estimated cap: about 11.3%. Past it, hit adds almost nothing.
No cap in the tested range: Crit keeps paying, about +6.92 DPS per 1 % at the start.
No cap in the tested range: Spell power keeps paying, about +0.51 DPS per point at the start.
No cap in the tested range: Intellect keeps paying, about +0.12 DPS per point at the start.
From the most to the least profitable for one unit of stat added to the simulated gear. Only the stats that bring DPS are listed.
Rule applied: at most one scroll, one elixir or flask, one food and one weapon oil at a time (the rule given for Forever, which the client tables cannot confirm). The simulator picks the best of each slot for this specialization; the best consumables and their gain are in its guide.
A 180-second fight against a stationary level-63 boss, the raid buffs and consumables of the class's family, a standard race (Human, Orc for Shaman) with the racials read from the game client (WoW Classic's weapon skill no longer exists in Forever: weapon specializations give critical strike chance), item effects on. Level-60 base stats and several Classic values are estimates, flagged in the simulator. Results will move with the game.
The core mechanics (attack table, rage, mana regeneration, resistances, Classic base stats and race bonuses) come from the open-source simulator WoWSims (MIT licence): github.com/wowsims/classic
World of Warcraft, Warcraft and Blizzard Entertainment are trademarks of Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. BrokenMeta.gg is an independent site: it is not affiliated with, endorsed or sponsored by Blizzard.